← New search
Cattaraugus County, NY · Sold

NY-991888

4125 County Road 96

$12,300
$5,694/ac · 2.16 ac
Acreage2.16 ac
Price per acre$5,694/ac
ZoningAgricultural
Road accessPaved
UtilitiesOff grid
TopographyRolling
ListedMay 31, 2024
Coordinates42.2517, -78.7434
Loading terrain…
County GIS boundary

We do not yet have an active public ArcGIS connection for this county. Use the official source link to verify the parcel boundary and flood/zoning layers.

County market

Cattaraugus County, New York. Upstate and Southern Tier acreage well below downstate expectations.

View Cattaraugus market data →

Step 1 · Is this a deal?

Due diligence

4 items to verify before you offer.

Risk index
26
Low risk
Wetlands14.5% of tract

Partial wetlands. Verify the delineated build envelope.

Average slope7.7%

Gentle grade, straightforward to develop.

Flood zoneShaded X

Moderate flood hazard on part of the tract.

Legal accessDeeded frontage

180 ft of deeded road frontage.

Power12,290 ft away

A long utility run — price in solar/off-grid instead.

Buildable area1.75 of 2.16 ac

Net of wetlands and slope constraints.

Step 2 · Where do the numbers land?

Adjusted value estimate
$15,635
$11,587$19,683 · $7,238/ac on 2.16 ac
Asking vs estimate
-21.3%
Priced below the comp set

Weighted from 6 recorded sales, adjusted for tract size, access, utilities and time since sale. Range width reflects dispersion across the comp set.

AI deal brief

Comps, diligence flags, an offer number and what to ask the seller.

Offer calculatorAsking $12,300
Maximum allowable offer
$8,934
$4,136/ac · +30.0% target margin

You need $3,366 off asking to hit this margin.

All-in cost$9,693
Net resale$14,384
Projected profit$4,691
ROI+48.4%
Annualized+69.3%
Break-even resale$4,878/ac
Profit if resale lands off target
-20%
$1,814
-10%
$3,252
0%
$4,691
+10%
$6,129
+20%
$7,567
Comparable sales6 matches
ParcelAcresSoldPrice$/acAdj $/acDistMatch
NY-762333
Dirt · Off grid
3.0Jun 9, 2026$12,1004,0525,6484.5 mi
81
NY-322501
Paved · Off grid
3.4Mar 20, 2025$22,5006,6907,1705.0 mi
74
NY-833250
Dirt · Off grid
5.8Jun 18, 2025$30,5005,2647,8392.6 mi
71
NY-942921
Gravel · Power at road
4.6Dec 20, 2025$20,8004,5564,8043.1 mi
70
NY-540654
Dirt · Power at road
0.9May 11, 2024$7,5008,52810,7522.0 mi
61
NY-760322
Gravel · Power at road
0.7Aug 30, 2024$5,2007,5808,10710.0 mi
55
Show adjustment detail for the top comp
  • Tract size (2.98 ac → 2.16 ac)+0.8%
  • Access (Dirt → Paved)+37.2%
  • Market time (2 mo)+0.8%

Step 3 · Market it

Turn this underwriting into a listing

Generate a comp-priced headline, listing description, land-group post and cash-buyer email for this tract — then post it to the investor marketplace.